Retrospective -더-: what you witnessed, and -던/-았던
B1 회상 -더라고요·-더니와 관형형 -던·-았던 57 / 68
In short
The retrospective -더- reports something you personally saw, heard, or felt in the past and are now recalling. In speech that is -더라고요 (“I noticed that…”) with its casual twin -더라; as a noun-modifier it is -던 (habitual or left unfinished) and -았/었던 (completed and now over). 그 카페 커피가 맛있더라고요 (masitdeoragoyo, the coffee there was good, I found).
The rule
-더- is Korean’s firsthand-evidence marker: it means the information came in through your own eyes, ears, or feelings on some past occasion. It never takes 으 and never splits by vowel harmony - it just clips straight onto any stem.
Step 1 - -더라고요: reporting what you witnessed
Verb/Adjective stem + -더라고요. It presents a fact as a fresh discovery you made: 어제 가 보니까 사람이 많더라고요 (manteoragoyo, there were a lot of people, I found). Stack the past -았/었더라고요 when the event was already finished when you noticed it: 벌써 갔더라고요 (gatdeoragoyo, it/he had already gone, I saw). For a noun it is -이더라고요: 학생이더라고요 (haksaengideoragoyo, turned out to be a student).
Step 2 - the person rule (this is the tricky part)
Because -더- reports what you observed from the outside, it clashes with your own actions - you can’t watch yourself. So report your own actions with the plain past instead. But it flips for feelings: your own inner reactions are exactly what -더- is for, while someone else’s feelings you can only infer, so those need -어하다.
- someone else’s action you saw -> 친구가 공부하더라고요 (chinguga gongbuhadeoragoyo, my friend was studying, I saw).
- your own action -> plain past: 저는 공부했어요 (jeoneun gongbuhaesseoyo), not 저는 공부하더라고요.
- your own feeling -> 저는 무섭더라고요 (jeoneun museopdeoragoyo, I found it scary).
- someone else’s feeling -> 친구는 무서워하더라고요 (chinguneun museowohadeoragoyo, my friend was scared).
Step 3 - the casual -더라 and the background -던데요
-더라 is the 반말 form of -더라고요, for friends: 그 영화 진짜 재미있더라 (jaemiitdeora, that movie was really fun). -던데요 (from -더- + -는데요, lesson 41) lays a witnessed fact down as background that invites a reaction: 아까 보니까 문이 열려 있던데요 (yeollyeo itdeondeyo, the door was open when I looked, you know). The past -았/었- stacks on -더라 and -던데요 exactly as it does on -더라고요 - 왔더라 (watdeora), 컸던데요 (keotdeondeyo) - and, unlike -더니, it changes nothing but the completeness of what you saw.
Step 4 - -더니 vs -았/었더니
-더니 links an earlier situation you watched to a change or result, and its subject is 2nd or 3rd person: 어제 아프더니 오늘은 괜찮네요 (eoje apeudeoni oneureun gwaenchanneyo, you/he were sick yesterday, and today you’re fine). Swap in the past -았/었더니 and it becomes first person: you did something, and then something followed - 아침을 안 먹었더니 배고파요 (achimeul an meogeotdeoni baegopayo, I skipped breakfast, so now I’m hungry).
Step 5 - the modifier forms -던, -았/었던, and plain -(으)ㄴ
As a noun-modifier, -더- becomes -던 and marks the past as recalled - either habitual (“used to”) or unfinished/interrupted: 다니던 학교 (danideon hakgyo, the school I used to attend), 마시던 커피 (masideon keopi, the coffee I was drinking). -았/었던 adds completion and discontinuity - it happened, and it’s now over or no longer true: 갔던 곳 (gatdeon got, the place I once went), 예뻤던 얼굴 (yeppeotdeon eolgul, the face that used to be pretty). Plain -(으)ㄴ (lesson 24) is the neutral completed past with none of that recall/discontinuity flavour: 먹은 빵 (meogeun ppang, the eaten bread).
Forms & patterns
The spoken -더- endings (they attach straight onto any stem - no 으, no vowel-harmony split):
| Ending | Job | After a vowel | After a 받침 |
|---|---|---|---|
| -더라고요 | report what you witnessed (해요체) | 가다 -> 가더라고요 (gadeoragoyo) | 먹다 -> 먹더라고요 (meokdeoragoyo) |
| -더라 | the same, casual (반말) | 오다 -> 오더라 (odeora), past 왔더라 (watdeora) | 좋다 -> 좋더라 (joteora) |
| -던데요 | witnessed background inviting a reply | 크다 -> 크던데요 (keudeondeyo), past 컸던데요 (keotdeondeyo) | 많다 -> 많던데요 (manteondeyo) |
| -더니 | witnessed X -> change/result (2nd/3rd person) | 자다 -> 자더니 (jadeoni) | 웃다 -> 웃더니 (utdeoni) |
The modifier forms (-던 attaches directly; -았/었던 needs the past, picked by vowel harmony):
| Form | What it recalls | Example | Gloss |
|---|---|---|---|
| -던 | habitual, “used to” | 다니다 -> 다니던 학교 (danideon hakgyo) | the school I used to attend |
| -던 | unfinished / interrupted | 마시다 -> 마시던 커피 (masideon keopi) | the coffee I was drinking |
| -았/었던 | completed, now over | 가다 -> 갔던 곳 (gatdeon got) | the place I once went |
| -았/었던 | past state, no longer true | 예쁘다 -> 예뻤던 얼굴 (yeppeotdeon eolgul) | the face that used to be pretty |
| -(으)ㄴ | plain completed past | 먹다 -> 먹은 빵 (meogeun ppang) | the (already) eaten bread |
-더니 vs -았/었더니 - the person and tense pivot:
| -더니 | -았/었더니 | |
|---|---|---|
| Subject | 2nd / 3rd person (someone you watched) | 1st person (I) |
| First clause | witnessed situation, present stem + 더니 | my own past action, past + 더니 |
| Meaning | ”was X, and then (changed / as a result)" | "I did X, and then Y happened / I found Y” |
| Example | 동생이 울더니 잠들었어요 (dongsaengi uldeoni jamdeureosseoyo) | (제가) 아침을 안 먹었더니 배고파요 (meogeotdeoni baegopayo) |
Person and evidence at a glance (-더- always encodes firsthand past evidence):
| You want to say… | Subject | Use | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| what you saw someone else do | 3rd | -더라고요 | 친구가 공부하더라고요 (chinguga gongbuhadeoragoyo) |
| your own past action | 1st | plain past, not -더- | 저는 공부했어요 (jeoneun gongbuhaesseoyo) |
| your own feeling / reaction | 1st | -더라고요 | 저는 무섭더라고요 (jeoneun museopdeoragoyo) |
| someone else’s feeling | 3rd | -어하다 + -더라고요 | 친구는 무서워하더라고요 (chinguneun museowohadeoragoyo) |
Examples
- 어제 명동에 사람이 정말 많더라고요. (Eoje Myeongdonge sarami jeongmal manteoragoyo.) - Yesterday there were really a lot of people in Myeongdong (I saw).
- 그 카페 커피가 맛있더라고요. (Geu kape keopiga masitdeoragoyo.) - The coffee at that cafe was good, I found.
- 저는 그 영화가 좀 무섭더라고요. (Jeoneun geu yeonghwaga jom museopdeoragoyo.) - I found that movie a bit scary.
- 그 사람 노래 진짜 잘하더라. (Geu saram norae jinjja jalhadeora.) - That person sang really well.
- 아까 보니까 문이 열려 있던데요. (Akka bonikka muni yeollyeo itdeondeyo.) - When I looked earlier, the door was open, you know.
- 동생이 한참 울더니 잠들었어요. (Dongsaengi hancham uldeoni jamdeureosseoyo.) - My little sibling cried for a while and then fell asleep.
- 매일 운동하더니 정말 건강해졌어요. (Maeil undonghadeoni jeongmal geonganghaejeosseoyo.) - He exercised every day and got really healthy.
- 아침을 안 먹었더니 지금 너무 배고파요. (Achimeul an meogeotdeoni jigeum neomu baegopayo.) - I skipped breakfast, so now I’m very hungry.
- 어릴 때 살았던 집에 다시 가 봤어요. (Eoril ttae saratdeon jibe dasi ga bwasseoyo.) - I went back to the house I lived in as a child.
- 제가 마시던 커피가 아직 여기 있어요. (Jega masideon keopiga ajik yeogi isseoyo.) - The coffee I was drinking is still here.
Common mistakes
- 저는 매일 학교에 가더라고요. (Jeoneun maeil hakgyoe gadeoragoyo.) -> 저는 매일 학교에 갔어요. (Jeoneun maeil hakgyoe gasseoyo.) - -더- reports what you watch from the outside, so it clashes with your own action; report your own actions with the plain past -았/었-.
- 친구는 그 영화가 무섭더라고요. (Chinguneun geu yeonghwaga museopdeoragoyo.) -> 친구는 그 영화를 무서워하더라고요. (Chinguneun geu yeonghwareul museowohadeoragoyo.) - a bare feeling-adjective + -더- can only describe your feeling; for someone else’s feeling use -어하다 (as written, 친구는 무섭더라고요 would mean “my friend was scary, I found”).
- 저는 아침을 안 먹더니 배고파요. (Jeoneun achimeul an meokdeoni baegopayo.) -> 저는 아침을 안 먹었더니 배고파요. (Jeoneun achimeul an meogeotdeoni baegopayo.) - when your own action causes the result, use -았/었더니 (past); plain -더니 needs a 2nd/3rd-person situation you witnessed.
- 책상 위에 마신 커피가 있어요. (Chaeksang wie masin keopiga isseoyo.) -> 책상 위에 마시던 커피가 있어요. (Chaeksang wie masideon keopiga isseoyo.) - 마신 = drank (finished, gone); coffee you left half-drunk is 마시던 (unfinished). -(으)ㄴ seals the action; -던 leaves it open.
- 그 집 진짜 좋더라구요. (Geu jip jinjja joteoraguyo.) -> 그 집 진짜 좋더라고요. (Geu jip jinjja joteoragoyo.) - the standard spelling is -더라고요; -더라구요 is a colloquial mis-spelling of the same ending.
Tips
- -더- means “I was there.” Everything built on it - -더라고요, -더라, -던데요, -더니, and the modifier -던 - carries firsthand past evidence: you saw, heard, or felt it yourself. That is what sets it apart from the second-hand hearsay -대요 (lesson 59).
- Own action -> no -더-; own feeling -> yes -더-. You can’t watch yourself act, but you can feel your own feelings, so 저는 무섭더라고요 is fine while 저는 가더라고요 is not.
- -던 leaves it open, -았/었던 seals it. Habitual or unfinished = -던 (마시던 커피 is still on the desk); done-and-over = -았/었던 (마셨던 커피 is long gone).
- -더니 pivots on 았/었. No past marker = someone you watched changed or reacted; add 았/었 with a 저/제 subject = your own action produced the result.