Pretérito mais-que-perfeito simples
C1 Pretérito mais-que-perfeito simples 55 / 55
In short
The pretérito mais-que-perfeito simples is the one-word “had done”: eu falara means exactly the same as eu tinha falado from step 25. In modern European Portuguese it has all but vanished from speech, surviving in literary and journalistic prose, in a handful of frozen exclamations (quem me dera, pudera), and in careful formal writing. Your practical goal at C1 is to recognize it instantly when you read it - it is easy to mistake for another form - and to remember that you can always fall back on the compound tinha + particípio when you speak. Hold one idea: same meaning as tinha feito, higher register.
The rule
What it means
It marks anteriority in the past - an action already finished before another past moment - and translates as English “had + past participle”:
- Quando a polícia chegou, o ladrão já fugira. = … já tinha fugido. (When the police arrived, the thief had already fled.)
Semantically it is interchangeable with the compound pretérito mais-que-perfeito composto (tinha + particípio) you met in step 25. The difference is register, not meaning.
How it is built
Take the eles form of the pretérito perfeito simples (steps 20-21), drop the ending -ram, and add -ra, -ras, -ra, -ramos, -reis, -ram. The nós and vós forms take a written accent to keep the stress where it belongs. Building it on the perfect stem is what makes it reliable: an irregular perfeito automatically yields an irregular pluperfect, so you never have to memorize a second irregular set.
One consequence to notice: the eles form is identical to the pretérito perfeito (eles falaram = both “they spoke” and “they had spoken”). Only context separates them - one more reason the tense lives mostly on the page, where the surrounding narrative makes the meaning clear.
Register: read it, rarely write it
This is a literary tense. In conversation and ordinary writing, European Portuguese uses tinha + particípio without exception. So treat the simple form as passive recognition plus optional formal production: you decode it in a novel or a news report (O ministro afirmara que…), and you may choose it yourself only in deliberately formal prose.
Fixed forms with a life of their own
A few pluperfect forms have frozen into set expressions and no longer mean “had done”:
- quem me dera (+ infinitive, or + que + imperfect subjunctive) = “if only, how I wish” - here dera is an optative formula, not “had given”.
- pudera! = “no wonder!, of course!” - an exclamation, unrelated to “had been able”.
- literary melhor fora / antes fora = “it would have been better”.
Learn these as vocabulary; they are far more frequent than the tense that spawned them.
Forms & patterns
The regular paradigm (from the eles-perfeito, minus -ram, plus the endings):
| Person | falar (falaram) | comer (comeram) | partir (partiram) |
|---|---|---|---|
| eu | falara | comera | partira |
| tu | falaras | comeras | partiras |
| ele/ela/você | falara | comera | partira |
| nós | faláramos | comêramos | partíramos |
| vós | faláreis | comêreis | partíreis |
| eles/elas/vocês | falaram | comeram | partiram |
Irregular verbs inherit the irregular perfect stem:
| Infinitive | Perfeito (eles) | Pluperfect (eu) | English |
|---|---|---|---|
| ser / ir | foram | fora | had been / gone |
| ter | tiveram | tivera | had had |
| fazer | fizeram | fizera | had done |
| dizer | disseram | dissera | had said |
| ver | viram | vira | had seen |
| vir | vieram | viera | had come |
| pôr | puseram | pusera | had put |
| trazer | trouxeram | trouxera | had brought |
| poder | puderam | pudera | had been able |
Simple (literary) vs compound (everyday) - identical meaning:
| Simple | Compound | English |
|---|---|---|
| eu falara | eu tinha falado | I had spoken |
| ela saíra | ela tinha saído | she had left |
| nós fôramos | nós tínhamos ido | we had gone |
| eles disseram | eles tinham dito | they had said |
Examples
| Português | English |
|---|---|
| Quando cheguei, ela já saíra. | When I arrived, she had already left. |
| O comboio partira antes das seis. | The train had left before six. |
| Ele contou o que vira na cidade. | He told what he had seen in the city. |
| Nunca estivera tão feliz. | He had never been so happy. |
| Já lêramos o relatório quando ele falou. | We had already read the report when he spoke. |
| A carta que ela me escrevera perdeu-se. | The letter she had written me got lost. |
| O jornalista afirmara que o acordo falhara. | The journalist had stated that the deal had failed. |
| Fizera tudo o que prometera. | He had done everything he had promised. |
| Quem me dera ter mais tempo! | If only I had more time! |
| Pudera! Estava cansadíssimo. | No wonder! He was exhausted. |
Common mistakes
- Building it from the infinitive -> from the eles-perfeito: not fazera but fizera (fizeram minus -ram, plus -ra); the irregular perfect stem carries straight over.
- Dropping the accent in the nós form -> faláramos, comêramos, partíramos, fôramos - without it the stress moves and the form is simply wrong.
- Using it out loud in casual speech -> say tinha saído, not saíra - the simple form sounds bookish in conversation.
- Confusing the -ra pluperfect with the -sse imperfect subjunctive (step 46) -> cantara = “had sung” (a fact) vs cantasse = “were to sing / sang” (hypothetical); they are not interchangeable.
- Quem me dera que é verdade! -> Quem me dera que fosse verdade! - quem me dera is a frozen wish (“if only!”), not a literal pluperfect: it takes an infinitive or que + imperfect subjunctive, never the indicative.
- Ontem fora ao Porto. (meaning “yesterday I went”) -> Ontem fui ao Porto. - fora means “had gone”, before another past moment; a plain past event takes the perfeito (fui). Do not confuse it with the adverb fora, “outside” (Ele está lá fora).
Tips
- Aim for recognition first: when a novel or news report shows an unexpected -ra ending on a verb, read it as tinha + particípio and keep going.
- To decode any form, reverse the process - add -m back to reach the eles-perfeito (fizera -> fizeram -> fazer), which reveals the infinitive.
- When you need anteriority yourself, the compound tinha feito is always correct and never sounds wrong; reserve the simple form for deliberately formal writing.
- Memorize the two idioms as vocabulary - quem me dera (“if only”) and pudera! (“no wonder!”) - since they are far commoner than the tense itself.
- Watch the homographs: vira (had seen, from ver) vs vira (turns, from virar); fora (had been) vs fora (outside); dera (had given) vs the set quem me dera.
- In Brazil: the simple pluperfect is even rarer in speech than in Portugal and is felt as markedly literary, but the same fixed forms (quem me dera, pudera) are fully alive in both norms.