Advanced relatives: o qual and cujo

B2 Relativos avançados: o qual e cujo 45 / 55

In short

Lesson 38 gave you the everyday relatives - que (the all-purpose one), quem (people, after a preposition) and onde (places). This lesson adds the two heavier relatives that careful, written European Portuguese leans on. O qual - with its forms a qual, os quais, as quais - is a longer, more explicit stand-in for que and quem: you reach for it after a preposition, to break an ambiguity, or inside a comma (non-restrictive) clause. Cujo - cuja, cujos, cujas - is the single word for “whose”, and it hides one sharp trap: it agrees not with the owner but with the thing owned, takes no article, and clamps straight onto the noun. Neither is optional polish: after a compound preposition EP refuses bare que, and cujo is the only correct way to relativize possession.

The rule

O qual has four forms and agrees with its antecedent

O qual is really the article o/a/os/as welded to qual, so it carries the gender and number of the noun it points back to (its antecedent):

SingularPlural
Masculineo qualos quais
Femininea qualas quais

O senhor a quem escrevi respondeu uses quem; the more formal o senhor ao qual escrevi respondeu uses o qual, and qual becomes a qual, os quais, as quais to match whatever it refers to.

When to use o qual instead of que

Bare que is still the default for a simple subject or object relative (o livro que comprei). Switch to o qual in three situations:

  1. After a preposition - and obligatorily after a compound preposition. With the simple prepositions de, em, por, a, com + a thing, both que and o qual occur, but after multi-word prepositions (ao lado de, por causa de, graças a, através de, dentro de, a respeito de) EP requires the qual/quem form and never bare que:
    • o motivo pelo qual vim - the reason I came.
    • o prédio ao lado do qual moro - the building next to which I live. (never ao lado de que)
  2. To remove ambiguity. Because o qual agrees, it can point cleanly at one of two possible antecedents where que would be vague: A irmã do médico, a qual vive em Lisboa, … (a qual, feminine = the sister) versus o qual, … (= the doctor).
  3. In non-restrictive (comma) clauses in careful or written register: O relatório, o qual foi divulgado ontem, provocou reações.

The preposition fuses with o qual, exactly like with an article

Every contraction you learned in Lesson 2 (and por -> pelo from Lesson 28) applies here unchanged, because o qual begins with an article:

Preposition +o quala qualos quaisas quais
dedo qualda qualdos quaisdas quais
emno qualna qualnos quaisnas quais
aao qualà qualaos quaisàs quais
porpelo qualpela qualpelos quaispelas quais

So it is na qual, pelo qual, à qual - never em a qual, por o qual, a a qual.

People after a preposition: quem or o qual, never que

For a person after a preposition, EP uses quem (Lesson 38) or, more formally, o qual - but not bare que:

  • o amigo com quem falei = o amigo com o qual falei - the friend I spoke to.
  • NOT o amigo com que falei (heard regionally, but outside the standard).

Cujo: the one word for “whose”

Cujo joins a possessor to a possessed thing and translates “whose” or “of which”. It has four forms and one iron rule: it agrees with the thing possessed, not the owner, carries no article, and sits immediately before that noun:

SingularPlural
Masculinecujocujos
Femininecujacujas
  • o escritor cujos livros li - the writer whose books I read. (cujos agrees with livros, not with escritor.)
  • a empresa cujo diretor conheço - the company whose director I know.
  • um problema cuja solução ninguém encontra - a problem whose solution nobody can find.

A preposition can precede cujo; it still agrees with the possessed noun and never contracts, since there is no article to fuse with:

  • a casa em cujo jardim brincávamos - the house in whose garden we used to play.
  • a autora a cujo estilo me habituei - the author whose style I got used to.
  • o tema sobre cujas implicações discutimos - the topic whose implications we discussed.

Forms & patterns

Choosing the relative after a preposition:

AntecedentSimple prepositionCompound preposition
thingde/em/por/a/com que or o qualonly o qual (do qual, ao lado do qual)
personquem or o qualonly quem / o qual
possession (“whose”)cujo (+ noun)prep + cujo (a cujo, em cujo)

Cujo agrees rightward - look at the noun that follows it:

OwnerPossessed nounResult
o autoros livros (m. pl)o autor cujos livros
a cidadeas praias (f. pl)a cidade cujas praias
o alunoa nota (f. sg)o aluno cuja nota

Examples

PortuguêsEnglish
A empresa para a qual trabalho fica no Porto.The company I work for is in Porto.
Estas são as razões pelas quais desistimos.These are the reasons why we gave up.
O comité, o qual se reúne à sexta, decidiu adiar.The committee, which meets on Fridays, decided to postpone.
É um assunto a respeito do qual nada sei.It’s a matter about which I know nothing.
Falei com a médica com quem já te tinhas consultado.I spoke to the doctor you had already seen.
O romancista cujos contos adoro vem cá amanhã.The novelist whose short stories I love is coming tomorrow.
Vivo numa rua cujo nome ninguém sabe pronunciar.I live on a street whose name nobody can pronounce.
A ponte sob a qual passámos é do século XIX.The bridge we passed under is from the 19th century.
Conheço o político a cujas promessas ninguém liga.I know the politician whose promises nobody heeds.
A casa em cujo sótão dormíamos foi vendida.The house in whose attic we used to sleep was sold.

Common mistakes

  • Que after a compound preposition: a razão por causa de que faltei -> por causa da qual - multi-word prepositions demand the qual form and its contraction.
  • An article after cujo: o homem cujo o carro bateu -> cujo carro - cujo already contains the idea of the article; nothing may sit between it and the noun.
  • Making cujo agree with the owner: a mulher cujo filhos vieram -> cujos filhos - it agrees with filhos (m. pl), never with mulher.
  • Using de que / de quem for the “whose” of a thing: a casa de que as janelas estão partidas -> cujas janelas - possession of a thing is always cujo.
  • Dropping the contraction: o fim por o qual lutamos / a sala em a qual entrámos -> pelo qual, na qual.
  • Bare que + preposition for a person: o colega a que pedi ajuda -> a quem (or ao qual).
  • Scattering o qual where plain que is natural: O bolo o qual fiz -> que fiz - without a preposition, in a restrictive clause, que is the correct default; o qual there sounds stilted.
  • In Brazil: the written norm is identical - o qual and cujo work exactly the same way. What differs is only casual speech, where Brazilian Portuguese often avoids both with a resumptive pattern (o autor que eu li os livros dele); that is nonstandard on both sides of the Atlantic, so keep cujo in writing.

Tips

  • After a preposition, ask two questions. Thing or person? Thing -> o/a qual (or bare que with the simple prepositions); person -> quem (or o qual). Simple or compound preposition? Compound -> always the qual/quem form, never que.
  • Cujo looks forward, not back: it takes its ending from the noun that follows it and snaps straight onto it, with no o/a in between - cujo carro, cujas ideias.
  • Contract on autopilot. Any preposition that fuses with o/a/os/as fuses with o qual too - do qual, no qual, pela qual, à qual - but cujo has no article, so it stays loose: a cujo, de cujo, em cujo.
  • Keep o qual in reserve. Plain que remains the everyday relative; reach for o qual only to (a) follow a preposition, (b) break an ambiguity between two possible antecedents, or (c) open a comma clause in careful writing.