Advanced relatives: o qual and cujo
B2 Relativos avançados: o qual e cujo 45 / 55
In short
Lesson 38 gave you the everyday relatives - que (the all-purpose one), quem (people, after a preposition) and onde (places). This lesson adds the two heavier relatives that careful, written European Portuguese leans on. O qual - with its forms a qual, os quais, as quais - is a longer, more explicit stand-in for que and quem: you reach for it after a preposition, to break an ambiguity, or inside a comma (non-restrictive) clause. Cujo - cuja, cujos, cujas - is the single word for “whose”, and it hides one sharp trap: it agrees not with the owner but with the thing owned, takes no article, and clamps straight onto the noun. Neither is optional polish: after a compound preposition EP refuses bare que, and cujo is the only correct way to relativize possession.
The rule
O qual has four forms and agrees with its antecedent
O qual is really the article o/a/os/as welded to qual, so it carries the gender and number of the noun it points back to (its antecedent):
| Singular | Plural | |
|---|---|---|
| Masculine | o qual | os quais |
| Feminine | a qual | as quais |
O senhor a quem escrevi respondeu uses quem; the more formal o senhor ao qual escrevi respondeu uses o qual, and qual becomes a qual, os quais, as quais to match whatever it refers to.
When to use o qual instead of que
Bare que is still the default for a simple subject or object relative (o livro que comprei). Switch to o qual in three situations:
- After a preposition - and obligatorily after a compound preposition. With the simple prepositions de, em, por, a, com + a thing, both que and o qual occur, but after multi-word prepositions (ao lado de, por causa de, graças a, através de, dentro de, a respeito de) EP requires the qual/quem form and never bare que:
- o motivo pelo qual vim - the reason I came.
- o prédio ao lado do qual moro - the building next to which I live. (never ao lado de que)
- To remove ambiguity. Because o qual agrees, it can point cleanly at one of two possible antecedents where que would be vague: A irmã do médico, a qual vive em Lisboa, … (a qual, feminine = the sister) versus o qual, … (= the doctor).
- In non-restrictive (comma) clauses in careful or written register: O relatório, o qual foi divulgado ontem, provocou reações.
The preposition fuses with o qual, exactly like with an article
Every contraction you learned in Lesson 2 (and por -> pelo from Lesson 28) applies here unchanged, because o qual begins with an article:
| Preposition + | o qual | a qual | os quais | as quais |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| de | do qual | da qual | dos quais | das quais |
| em | no qual | na qual | nos quais | nas quais |
| a | ao qual | à qual | aos quais | às quais |
| por | pelo qual | pela qual | pelos quais | pelas quais |
So it is na qual, pelo qual, à qual - never em a qual, por o qual, a a qual.
People after a preposition: quem or o qual, never que
For a person after a preposition, EP uses quem (Lesson 38) or, more formally, o qual - but not bare que:
- o amigo com quem falei = o amigo com o qual falei - the friend I spoke to.
- NOT o amigo com que falei (heard regionally, but outside the standard).
Cujo: the one word for “whose”
Cujo joins a possessor to a possessed thing and translates “whose” or “of which”. It has four forms and one iron rule: it agrees with the thing possessed, not the owner, carries no article, and sits immediately before that noun:
| Singular | Plural | |
|---|---|---|
| Masculine | cujo | cujos |
| Feminine | cuja | cujas |
- o escritor cujos livros li - the writer whose books I read. (cujos agrees with livros, not with escritor.)
- a empresa cujo diretor conheço - the company whose director I know.
- um problema cuja solução ninguém encontra - a problem whose solution nobody can find.
A preposition can precede cujo; it still agrees with the possessed noun and never contracts, since there is no article to fuse with:
- a casa em cujo jardim brincávamos - the house in whose garden we used to play.
- a autora a cujo estilo me habituei - the author whose style I got used to.
- o tema sobre cujas implicações discutimos - the topic whose implications we discussed.
Forms & patterns
Choosing the relative after a preposition:
| Antecedent | Simple preposition | Compound preposition |
|---|---|---|
| thing | de/em/por/a/com que or o qual | only o qual (do qual, ao lado do qual) |
| person | quem or o qual | only quem / o qual |
| possession (“whose”) | cujo (+ noun) | prep + cujo (a cujo, em cujo) |
Cujo agrees rightward - look at the noun that follows it:
| Owner | Possessed noun | Result |
|---|---|---|
| o autor | os livros (m. pl) | o autor cujos livros |
| a cidade | as praias (f. pl) | a cidade cujas praias |
| o aluno | a nota (f. sg) | o aluno cuja nota |
Examples
| Português | English |
|---|---|
| A empresa para a qual trabalho fica no Porto. | The company I work for is in Porto. |
| Estas são as razões pelas quais desistimos. | These are the reasons why we gave up. |
| O comité, o qual se reúne à sexta, decidiu adiar. | The committee, which meets on Fridays, decided to postpone. |
| É um assunto a respeito do qual nada sei. | It’s a matter about which I know nothing. |
| Falei com a médica com quem já te tinhas consultado. | I spoke to the doctor you had already seen. |
| O romancista cujos contos adoro vem cá amanhã. | The novelist whose short stories I love is coming tomorrow. |
| Vivo numa rua cujo nome ninguém sabe pronunciar. | I live on a street whose name nobody can pronounce. |
| A ponte sob a qual passámos é do século XIX. | The bridge we passed under is from the 19th century. |
| Conheço o político a cujas promessas ninguém liga. | I know the politician whose promises nobody heeds. |
| A casa em cujo sótão dormíamos foi vendida. | The house in whose attic we used to sleep was sold. |
Common mistakes
- Que after a compound preposition: a razão por causa de que faltei -> por causa da qual - multi-word prepositions demand the qual form and its contraction.
- An article after cujo: o homem cujo o carro bateu -> cujo carro - cujo already contains the idea of the article; nothing may sit between it and the noun.
- Making cujo agree with the owner: a mulher cujo filhos vieram -> cujos filhos - it agrees with filhos (m. pl), never with mulher.
- Using de que / de quem for the “whose” of a thing: a casa de que as janelas estão partidas -> cujas janelas - possession of a thing is always cujo.
- Dropping the contraction: o fim por o qual lutamos / a sala em a qual entrámos -> pelo qual, na qual.
- Bare que + preposition for a person: o colega a que pedi ajuda -> a quem (or ao qual).
- Scattering o qual where plain que is natural: O bolo o qual fiz -> que fiz - without a preposition, in a restrictive clause, que is the correct default; o qual there sounds stilted.
- In Brazil: the written norm is identical - o qual and cujo work exactly the same way. What differs is only casual speech, where Brazilian Portuguese often avoids both with a resumptive pattern (o autor que eu li os livros dele); that is nonstandard on both sides of the Atlantic, so keep cujo in writing.
Tips
- After a preposition, ask two questions. Thing or person? Thing -> o/a qual (or bare que with the simple prepositions); person -> quem (or o qual). Simple or compound preposition? Compound -> always the qual/quem form, never que.
- Cujo looks forward, not back: it takes its ending from the noun that follows it and snaps straight onto it, with no o/a in between - cujo carro, cujas ideias.
- Contract on autopilot. Any preposition that fuses with o/a/os/as fuses with o qual too - do qual, no qual, pela qual, à qual - but cujo has no article, so it stays loose: a cujo, de cujo, em cujo.
- Keep o qual in reserve. Plain que remains the everyday relative; reach for o qual only to (a) follow a preposition, (b) break an ambiguity between two possible antecedents, or (c) open a comma clause in careful writing.