Trying something and having done it before

A2 -아/어 보다와 -(으)ㄴ 적이 있다 35 / 68

In short

To say try doing something, add the auxiliary 보다 (literally to see) to the 아/어 form: 먹어 보세요 (meogeo boseyo, give it a taste). Put that same 보다 into the past and it flips to meaning have done / have experienced: 먹어 봤어요 (meogeo bwasseoyo, I’ve tried it). To spell out “have you ever…”, use the bound-noun frame -(으)ㄴ 적이 있다/없다: 제주도에 가 본 적이 있어요 (Jejudoe ga bon jeogi isseoyo, I’ve been to Jeju).

The rule

Step 1 - -아/어 보다: try doing it

Take the 아/어 form (lesson 10) and add 보다 as a separate word (it is an auxiliary, so it keeps its space): 먹다 -> 먹어 보다 (meogeo boda), 가다 -> 가 보다 (ga boda), 하다 -> 해 보다 (hae boda). Conjugate the 보다, not the main verb:

  • Suggestion - try it: 입어 보세요 (ibeo boseyo, try it on).
  • Volunteering - I’ll give it a go: 입어 볼게요 (ibeo bolgeyo, I’ll try it on).

One block: you cannot stack 보다 onto 보다 itself - 보다 already means “look”. *봐 보다 is wrong; to say “give it a look” use 한번 보세요 (hanbeon boseyo) or just 한번 봐요 (hanbeon bwayo). The pair negates as one block too, and the two negations split: the short 안/못 go in front of the main verb, never in front of 보다 - 못 가 봤어요 (mot ga bwasseoyo, I’ve never got to go), never *가 못 봤어요 - while the long -지 않다 / -지 못하다 attach to 보다 itself: 먹어 보지 않았어요 (meogeo boji anasseoyo), 먹어 보지 못했어요 (meogeo boji mothaesseoyo).

Step 2 - -아/어 봤어요: the past = an experience

Put 보다 in the past (보 + 았어요 -> 봤어요) and the meaning shifts from attempt to experience - I have done it (at least once): 한국 음식을 먹어 봤어요 (Hanguk eumsigeul meogeo bwasseoyo, I’ve tried Korean food). This is the everyday way to say “have you ever…”: 가 봤어요? (ga bwasseoyo?, have you been?).

Step 3 - -(으)ㄴ 적이 있다/없다: the explicit “have the experience of”

Attach the past modifier -(으)ㄴ to the verb, then the bound noun 적 (occasion) plus 있다 (there is) or 없다 (there isn’t). 적 is a separate word, so it always takes a space before it: 간 적이 있어요 (gan jeogi isseoyo, I have been), 먹은 적이 없어요 (meogeun jeogi eopseoyo, I’ve never eaten it). Negate with 없다, never *안 있다.

The two patterns stack: -아/어 보다 keeps its 보다, which is then modified as 본 -> -아/어 본 적이 있다. This is the most natural “have you ever tried…”: 제주도에 가 본 적이 있어요 (Jejudoe ga bon jeogi isseoyo), 번지점프를 해 본 적이 없어요 (beonjijeompeureul hae bon jeogi eopseoyo, I’ve never done bungee jumping).

Step 4 - Experience vs. plain event, and why recent things resist 적이 있다

갔어요 (gasseoyo) states a specific event - I went. 가 봤어요 / 간 적이 있어요 report an experience - I have (at some point) been. Because 적이 있다 packages the past as a notable, countable occasion, it clashes with events that are recent or routine: *어제 학교에 간 적이 있어요 is odd - going to school yesterday is an ordinary recent event, so just say 어제 학교에 갔어요. Reserve 적이 있다 for things worth calling an experience.

Step 5 - 적 vs 번

적 is a bound noun meaning the time or occasion of doing X; in this experience frame it takes the past modifier, -(으)ㄴ … 적이 있다. It also turns up after -(으)ㄹ meaning plain “when” - 어릴 적 (eoril jeok, “when I was little”) - but that is a time expression, not an experience claim. 번 (lesson 19) is a counter for counting how many times: 두 번 가 봤어요 (du beon ga bwasseoyo, I’ve been twice). Do not swap them: *간 번이 있어요 is wrong. Note also 한 번 (han beon, “one time”, spaced) vs 한번 (hanbeon, “give it a try, sometime”, one word) - the try-it 한번 sits happily in front of -아/어 보다.

Forms & patterns

-아/어 보다 - the 아/어 form plus the auxiliary 보다:

Stem아/어 form + 보다Meaning
가다 (go)가 보다 (ga boda)try going
먹다 (eat)먹어 보다 (meogeo boda)try eating
입다 (wear)입어 보다 (ibeo boda)try on
하다 (do)해 보다 (hae boda)try doing
쓰다 (use)써 보다 (sseo boda)try using

One verb, the whole range (먹다):

Form한글ReadsForce
suggestion먹어 보세요meogeo boseyotry it
volunteering먹어 볼게요meogeo bolgeyoI’ll try it
past = experience먹어 봤어요meogeo bwasseoyoI’ve tried it
stacked frame먹어 본 적이 있어요meogeo bon jeogi isseoyoI have tried it
negative experience안 먹어 봤어요an meogeo bwasseoyoI’ve never tried it

-(으)ㄴ 적이 있다 - the past modifier by last sound of the stem:

After…modifierExample
vowel stem-ㄴ 적이 있다가다 -> 간 적이 있어요 (gan jeogi isseoyo)
받침 stem-은 적이 있다먹다 -> 먹은 적이 있어요 (meogeun jeogi isseoyo)
ㄹ-stem (ㄹ drops)-ㄴ 적이 있다살다 -> 산 적이 있어요 (san jeogi isseoyo)
아/어 본 stack-아/어 본 적이 있다가 보다 -> 가 본 적이 있어요 (ga bon jeogi isseoyo)

Event vs. experience:

FormReadsMeaningUse
갔어요gasseoyo(I) wenta specific past event
가 봤어요ga bwasseoyo(I) have beenexperience, “ever”
간 적이 있어요gan jeogi isseoyo(I) have the experience of goingexperience, made explicit

Examples

  • 이 김치 한번 먹어 보세요. (I gimchi hanbeon meogeo boseyo.) - Try this kimchi.
  • 이 옷 입어 볼게요. (I ot ibeo bolgeyo.) - I’ll try this on.
  • 한국 음식을 먹어 봤어요? (Hanguk eumsigeul meogeo bwasseoyo?) - Have you tried Korean food?
  • 제주도에 가 본 적이 있어요. (Jejudoe ga bon jeogi isseoyo.) - I’ve been to Jeju.
  • 저는 번지점프를 해 본 적이 없어요. (Jeoneun beonjijeompeureul hae bon jeogi eopseoyo.) - I’ve never done bungee jumping.
  • 그 사람을 만난 적이 있어요. (Geu sarameul mannan jeogi isseoyo.) - I have met that person before.
  • 거기 두 번 가 봤어요. (Geogi du beon ga bwasseoyo.) - I’ve been there twice.
  • 그 영화 아직 못 봤어요. 한번 보세요. (Geu yeonghwa ajik mot bwasseoyo. Hanbeon boseyo.) - I haven’t seen that movie yet. Give it a watch.

Common mistakes

  • 그 영화 한번 봐 보세요. (Geu yeonghwa hanbeon bwa boseyo.) -> 그 영화 한번 보세요. (Geu yeonghwa hanbeon boseyo.) - you cannot add try-보다 to 보다 itself; the plain verb already means take a look.
  • 한국에 간적이 있어요. (Hanguge ganjeogi isseoyo.) -> 한국에 간 적이 있어요. (Hanguge gan jeogi isseoyo.) - 적 is a bound noun and needs a space before it; it is never glued to the modifier.
  • 어제 학교에 간 적이 있어요. (Eoje hakgyoe gan jeogi isseoyo.) -> 어제 학교에 갔어요. (Eoje hakgyoe gasseoyo.) - a recent, routine event takes the plain past; 적이 있다 is for notable experiences, not yesterday’s commute.
  • 한국에 간 번이 있어요. (Hanguge gan beoni isseoyo.) -> 한국에 간 적이 있어요. (Hanguge gan jeogi isseoyo.) - use 적 for experience; 번 only counts how many times (두 번, 세 번).
  • 만나 본 적이 안 있어요. (Manna bon jeogi an isseoyo.) -> 만나 본 적이 없어요. (Manna bon jeogi eopseoyo.) - negate 있다 with its own antonym 없다, not with 안.

Tips

  • 보다 = “see”, so the mnemonic writes itself: 먹어 보다 is eat and see -> try eating. The literal see meaning is exactly why you can’t stack it on 보다.
  • Same auxiliary, tense flips the meaning. Present/imperative 보다 = attempt (먹어 보세요, try it); past 봤어요 = experience (먹어 봤어요, I’ve had it). Watch the tense to know which reading is meant.
  • 적 wants a space, 번 wants a number. If you can put a count in front (two times), it’s 번; if you mean the occasion of ever doing it, it’s -(으)ㄴ 적이 있다. And 한 번도 (han beondo, not once) is that same 번 in its negative shape - it can only ever be finished with 없다, 안 or 못: 한 번도 가 본 적이 없어요 (han beondo ga bon jeogi eopseoyo), never *한 번도 가 봤어요.
  • Recent or habitual? Drop 적이 있다. For last week, this morning, or everyday actions, plain 갔어요 / 먹었어요 is right; save 적이 있다 for real “life experience” claims.