Existence with あります/います and position nouns
A1 存在文「あります・います」と位置名詞 9 / 69
In short
Japanese has two verbs for “there is”: あります (arimasu) for things that cannot move themselves, and います (imasu) for people and animals. The frame is Place + に + Thing + が + あります/います, and if you need a more precise place you build it with a position noun: 机の上に (tsukue no ue ni) - on the desk.
The rule
Step 1 - choose the verb by animacy, not by English. English uses one verb (“there is”) for everything; Japanese splits it in two.
- います - anything that moves under its own power: people (学生がいます gakusei ga imasu - there are students), animals, insects.
- あります - everything else: objects, buildings, plants and trees (a tree is alive but rooted, so 木があります ki ga arimasu), and also events (会議があります kaigi ga arimasu - there is a meeting) and abstract things (時間があります jikan ga arimasu - there is time).
Step 2 - use the existence frame. The pattern is Place + に + Thing + が + あります/います.
- に marks the place of existence. Not で - で is for a place where an action is performed.
- The thing that exists is marked with が, because it is new information being introduced.
- The negatives are simply ありません / いません, and the past is ありました / いました.
Step 3 - flip the order when the thing is already known. The two framings carry different information structure, and picking the wrong one is the commonest fluency error at this level.
- 〜に〜があります (place first, thing marked が): the place is given, the thing is new. This answers “What is in the room?” - 部屋にテレビがあります (Heya ni terebi ga arimasu).
- 〜は〜にあります (thing first, marked は): the thing is given, the place is new. This answers “Where is the bank?” - 銀行は駅の前にあります (Ginkō wa eki no mae ni arimasu).
So the rule of thumb: whatever you are telling the listener goes late and takes が; whatever you are both already talking about goes first and takes は.
Step 4 - build the place with a position noun. A position noun is an ordinary noun meaning “top”, “inside”, “front”. You attach it to the reference object with の, and the whole phrase then takes に:
Noun + の + position noun + に
机 (desk) + の + 上 (top) + に = 机の上に (tsukue no ue ni) - “on the desk”, literally “at the desk’s top”. The の and the に are both obligatory.
Step 5 - には topicalizes or contrasts a location. Add は after に to make the place the topic, or to imply a contrast with somewhere else.
- 私の部屋にはテレビがありません (Watashi no heya ni wa terebi ga arimasen) - “In my room there is no TV” (implying: elsewhere there may well be one). Note the romaji: に + は is ni wa, never “ni ha”.
Step 6 - the same verbs express possession. Japanese does not need a verb “to have”. The possessor is the topic は, and the thing possessed simply exists:
- 私は車があります (Watashi wa kuruma ga arimasu) - I have a car.
- 私は兄弟がいます (Watashi wa kyōdai ga imasu) - I have siblings (animate, so います).
The alternative is 持っています (motte imasu, “hold/own”), which asserts actual ownership or physical holding - 鍵を持っています (kagi o motte imasu). It takes を, not が, and it is not used for the family you simply have: ×兄弟を持っています is wrong - say 兄弟がいます.
A preview. When you list several things that exist, you connect them with や (“and, among others”) and often close with など (“and so on”): 机の上に本やノートなどがあります (Tsukue no ue ni hon ya nōto nado ga arimasu). Full listing comes in step 29.
Forms & patterns
Which verb - the animacy test.
| Subject | Verb | Example |
|---|---|---|
| People | います | 学生がいます (gakusei ga imasu) - there are students |
| Animals, insects | います | 犬がいます (inu ga imasu) - there is a dog |
| Plants, trees | あります | 木があります (ki ga arimasu) - there is a tree |
| Objects, buildings | あります | 本があります (hon ga arimasu) - there is a book |
| Events, appointments | あります | 会議があります (kaigi ga arimasu) - there is a meeting |
| Abstract things (time, money) | あります | 時間があります (jikan ga arimasu) - there is time |
| Vehicle as a possession or object | あります | 車があります (kuruma ga arimasu) - there is a car |
| Vehicle seen as moving or under way | います | タクシーがいます (takushī ga imasu) - there is a taxi (on the move) |
The polite paradigm.
| あります (inanimate) | います (animate) | |
|---|---|---|
| Dictionary form | ある (aru) | いる (iru) |
| Non-past | あります (arimasu) | います (imasu) |
| Non-past negative | ありません (arimasen) | いません (imasen) |
| Past | ありました (arimashita) | いました (imashita) |
| Past negative | ありませんでした (arimasen deshita) | いませんでした (imasen deshita) |
The two framings.
| Framing | Pattern | Given | New | Answers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Place first | Place に + Thing が + あります | the place | the thing | 部屋に何がありますか (Heya ni nani ga arimasu ka) - What is in the room? |
| Thing first | Thing は + Place に + あります | the thing | the place | 銀行はどこにありますか (Ginkō wa doko ni arimasu ka) - Where is the bank? |
Position nouns - all used as Noun + の + position noun + に.
| Position noun | Romaji | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| 上 | ue | on, above | 机の上に (tsukue no ue ni) - on the desk |
| 下 | shita | under, below | いすの下に (isu no shita ni) - under the chair |
| 中 | naka | inside | かばんの中に (kaban no naka ni) - in the bag |
| 前 | mae | in front of | 駅の前に (eki no mae ni) - in front of the station |
| 後ろ | ushiro | behind | 家の後ろに (ie no ushiro ni) - behind the house |
| 横 | yoko | at the side of | 車の横に (kuruma no yoko ni) - beside the car |
| 隣 | tonari | next door to (same kind of thing) | 銀行の隣に (ginkō no tonari ni) - next to the bank |
| そば | soba | close to, near | 学校のそばに (gakkō no soba ni) - near the school |
| 間 | aida | between | AとBの間に (A to B no aida ni) - between A and B |
| 右 | migi | to the right of | ドアの右に (doa no migi ni) - to the right of the door |
| 左 | hidari | to the left of | ドアの左に (doa no hidari ni) - to the left of the door |
Examples
- 机の上に本があります。 (Tsukue no ue ni hon ga arimasu.) - There is a book on the desk.
- 教室に学生がいます。 (Kyōshitsu ni gakusei ga imasu.) - There are students in the classroom.
- 銀行は駅の前にあります。 (Ginkō wa eki no mae ni arimasu.) - The bank is in front of the station.
- 田中さんは今事務所にいません。 (Tanaka-san wa ima jimusho ni imasen.) - Mr Tanaka is not in the office now.
- かばんの中に財布がありません。 (Kaban no naka ni saifu ga arimasen.) - There is no wallet in the bag.
- 私の部屋にはテレビがありません。 (Watashi no heya ni wa terebi ga arimasen.) - In my room, at least, there is no TV.
- 銀行と郵便局の間にコンビニがあります。 (Ginkō to yūbinkyoku no aida ni konbini ga arimasu.) - There is a convenience store between the bank and the post office.
- いすの下に猫がいました。 (Isu no shita ni neko ga imashita.) - There was a cat under the chair.
- 明日日本語の試験があります。 (Ashita nihongo no shiken ga arimasu.) - There is a Japanese exam tomorrow.
- 今日は時間がありません。 (Kyō wa jikan ga arimasen.) - I have no time today.
Common mistakes
- 部屋に猫があります -> 部屋に猫がいます (Heya ni neko ga imasu.) - a cat moves under its own power, so it is animate and takes います. The reverse trap is just as common: a tree does not move, so 木があります.
- 部屋でテレビがあります -> 部屋にテレビがあります (Heya ni terebi ga arimasu.) - existence is located with に; で is only for a place where an action is carried out.
- 机の上本があります -> 机の上に本があります (Tsukue no ue ni hon ga arimasu.) - the position noun does not replace the particle. You still need に after 上, and の before it.
- 銀行がどこにありますか -> 銀行はどこにありますか (Ginkō wa doko ni arimasu ka.) - the bank is the thing you already have in mind, so it is the topic は; が would wrongly put the new information on the bank itself.
- 私は車を持ちます -> 私は車を持っています (Watashi wa kuruma o motte imasu.) - possession is a state, so 持つ must be in the 〜ています form; the bare 持ちます is the one-off act of taking something in your hand or carrying it, not the state of owning it. For people, use いる instead: 兄弟がいます.
Tips
- The animacy mnemonic: can it decide to walk away? If yes, います. If no, あります. That single question resolves people, animals, plants, cars, buildings and appointments correctly. The famous grey zone is vehicles: a parked or merely available taxi is タクシーがあります, while タクシーがいます construes it as a mover, on the road or under way.
- English “have” splits into three Japanese patterns. Existence-possession of things: 車があります. Of people: 兄弟がいます. Physically holding or owning something: 鍵を持っています - and note the particle change from が to を.
- Position nouns are ordinary nouns, so they behave like any other place word. そば and 近く (chikaku) both mean “near” (そば is closer, 近く is “in the general vicinity”), and both take the same の frame: 学校の近くに (gakkō no chikaku ni). The final particle is not fixed to に either - swap in で when something happens there rather than exists there: 駅の前で待ちます (eki no mae de machimasu) - I will wait in front of the station.
- ある is irregular where you least expect it: its plain negative is ない (nai), never ×あらない. The polite ありません hides this, but the irregularity resurfaces the moment you meet plain forms in step 17.